When I was nineteen I hadn't been married very long and I certainly wasn’t thinking about having babies, a friend of mine invited me to participate in the home birth of her second child. That event changed my life. I had never before seen a baby being born. It was powerful and beautiful. The doctor and midwife who attended my friend collaborated with her every step of the way. That birth became the standard by which I judged how birth should be.
A couple of years later when I was pregnant, I wanted to have a birth similar to the one in which I had participated at my friend's home. I read everything I could get my hands on. There was not much literature published at the time that supported home birth, but there were some books available about "natural" childbirth.
I chose the same doctor who had attended my friend's birth. He was one of a very few doctors who participated in out-of-hospital births and was open to natural birth in general. The midwife who worked for him had trained in England and was working as his "assistant." At that time few midwives could be licensed in the United States so her practice was clandestine; she functioned under the protective umbrella of the doctor as a lowly handmaiden. Although she did most of my prenatal care she could not be at mine because she was not allowed to attend any hospital births. She assisted the doctor at the home births only and my husband and I weren't ready for the responsibility of having a baby at home, so we naively planned a natural childbirth in a hospital.
Shortly before my due date, I felt the baby stop moving. That didn't seem right to me, but some friends who had babies assured me I was overreacting. They said it was natural for a growing baby who is running out of room to stop moving. I was young and inexperienced enough to think that I would be bothering the doctor if I called him to discuss my fears. I didn't know any better and tried to quiet the still, small voice inside that said something was very wrong. But somewhere, deep inside, a spark went out. I did not know it in my mind and could not have articulated what I felt, but from then until the birth, I just seemed to be going through the motions. My denial was strong as my mind worked overtime not to allow my true feelings of fear to surface. I kept telling myself over and over that everything was fine. A couple of days later I went into labor.
At the hospital, the nurses were having a hard time finding my baby's heartbeat with the stethoscope, so they placed an electric fetal heart monitor on my big, pregnant belly. This was 1975, it was a fairly new device at the time and was very unfamiliar to us. The monitor produces a graph of the baby's heartbeat and uterine contractions on a continuously moving strip of graph paper. The squiggly top line is a depiction of the heartbeat and the lower line, which looks like a range of softly rounded mountains, is the image of the contractions.
My husband used the contraction graph to help with his coaching. He could see a contraction starting before I could feel it and would tell me to start breathing and relaxing. But we didn't know how to decipher all of the markings. I saw the continuous flat line on the top portion of the graph and wondered what it meant. I asked him what he thought it was. I don't recall what he said, but I do remember that we both looked away from it and never said another word about that flat line. I think we both knew what it meant, but were afraid to face it. I had to get through labor and I think I would have given up if I knew that all my work was to be in vain.
The nurses did not inform me of their findings that my baby had died. Instead, they kept offering me narcotics that I adamantly refused, again and again. It wasn't easy, by any means, to continue refusing their pharmaceutical pain-relief. My labor had been induced with Pitocin, and one contraction would turn into three without a pause between them. The monitor strip showed these as "triple peaks." Just as I thought the contraction should be going away, another would start up and become even stronger than the first one, then start to subside, then a third would begin, and again become stronger yet. This is common with Pitocin labors, making them incredibly difficult to cope with. There is nothing, no classes, no films, and no books that could have prepared me for what labor felt like. I was shocked at the intensity and sheer power of those contractions.
Despite the pain of labor, I was determined to have this baby without any narcotics or regional anesthetics. I wanted to be awake during labor and I knew that narcotics would make me groggy. I wanted to be an active participant in my birth! I wanted to feel the entire process. After eleven hours of chemically enhanced labor, my body was finally ready to birth my baby.
After pushing a couple of times in the labor room, the nurses saw that I was making very rapid progress which necessitated moving me to the delivery room. The nurses brought in a gurney and said, "Just hop on over, sweetie!" Without any concern for the sensations I was engulfed in, they made me push my weary body onto a gurney and then, after being rolled into the delivery room, I had to move onto the delivery table. I don't really remember how I did it; I was so engrossed in the overwhelming feelings of birthing that everything else was secondary.
Once I was on the delivery table, the nurses grabbed my legs to put them in the stirrups and strapped them down to keep me from being able to move them. Now I was flat on my back with my legs elevated and wide apart. I protested about how uncomfortable the position was but the nurses weren't interested in what I wanted. But I didn't have much time to fret about it. I had to PUSH!
With each contraction I had my husband hold me up in a semi-sitting position to help me push more effectively. What a strange feeling pushing was! I could feel my pelvis adjusting to accommodate the baby's head. But it felt like I was coming apart at the seams. In my childbirth classes the teacher had assured us that pushing would feel good. I kept saying over and over, "I thought this was supposed to feel good!" Good is not the word I would use to describe it at all. Extremely intense, feeling like I was pushing out a watermelon, feeling like my body was going to split open, but not good. I liked the active involvement pushing required and in the abdominal area it felt better to push than trying to relax during contractions. But the intense pelvic pressure overpowered those feelings.
I did not have to push for very long, and with the final push my sweet baby was born--still, perfect, quiet, white, and limp. She didn't cry, and she didn't move. The doctor laid her on my belly and I asked, "Is she alive?" He responded, "I think you know the answer to that." He was right. I did know. I had known in my body all along. But, I hadn't consciously known. It had been buried deep in my subconscious where I could ignore it and pretend it wasn't true. But whether I knew or not, it did not make it any easier to cope with.
My husband and I gazed at our daughter in disbelief and shock; stunned and helpless. Neither the nurses nor the doctor encouraged us to hold her or touch her or to grieve. Not one of them in that delivery room asked, "Do you want to hold her?" No one wrapped her in a blanket to help ease the harsh reality. No one said, "I'm so sorry. You must really be hurting." No one said anything, as if avoiding the subject would make it go away or make it easier for them. We just stared at our baby as the nurses stared at us. Finally I told them, "You can take her now." There seemed to be a time limit. I felt a lot of pressure to hurry up and be done with it already. The nurses seemed to be disgusted by this cold, dead baby, my lifeless firstborn; unabashedly disgusted. One of them picked up my still, wet, naked baby by one arm and one leg, carrying her off with her head and body dangling as if she were some piece of meat and not my precious daughter.
I was twenty-one and I was devastated. I still hurt from this. Not just from the intolerable experience of losing a child, but from the heartless and uncompassionate actions of the nurses in that delivery room.
Returning home to the room full of baby clothes and all that goes with it was like rubbing salt into my deeply wounded soul. My arms were empty. My heart was broken. The depth of my sorrow is beyond description. Oddly though, I felt another, equally powerful realization as well. Deep inside my self, I knew I had become a woman. I had birthed a baby. Interwoven with the grief, I felt powerful. I had labored and given birth without any drugs, under my own power, with my own strength. It had been a difficult labor because of the Pitocin and the death, but I had made it through with integrity. I had entered into it with the ideal of not using any drugs and had accomplished it. It felt like I had gone through an incredibly tough rite of passage and now I was on the other side.
I had joined the long line of strong women throughout history that birthed their babies with an impassioned strength that saturated my being and made it clear that I was a woman.